The Next Straw Hat Crew Member (During Punk Hazard Arc)

**cross777** · 03-18-2011, 03:10 AM

^and they only have 2 swords men. and then we should expect a swords men since most people expect that the least LOL.

Originally Posted by FenixMarco

Do you not understand the basics and limits of this manga even after 618 chapters. We won't get a powerhouse end of story. Yes everyone in the crew besides the monster trio is strong but they aren't highlighted as the monster trio in that way. You also make the assumption like that's the only way to go show someone's strong just with pure strength.

"Oda can still make it cool and interesting" NO! "Oda can make anything happen!" and NO! Oda is only human just like us, he has limits and makes mistakes like us.

Another swordsmen/swordswomen w/e the f*ck is boring idea coming from Oda, notice how the crew is nearly completely different from one another. Like dct said it's over kill. What is the point on adding another sword user who won't be better than Zoro and probably just be better than Brooke? That's isn't cool or interesting if that's where your trying to get out.

Damn get it through your head it's Oda's imagination not yours, none of this makes sense when you see how his story flows. Oda can't do it, he has human blood flowing through his veins.

THATS YOU OPINION AND I RESPECT THAT !

but if you think the swords men or woman idea is lame why are you still on the ninja idea? i mean its very likely if a ninja joins the crew he or she has a very good chance of using a sword.

**dct21** · 03-18-2011, 03:56 AM

swords with a DF would be really different

i always said zoro was gonna get a fire sword, even Zoro mentioned his interest in one

but if you think the swords men or woman idea is lame why are you still on the ninja idea? i mean its very likely if a ninja joins the crew he or she has a very good chance of using a sword.

NAruto never used a sword

**xioaxioa** · 03-18-2011, 04:00 AM

A Swordsman is not a Swordsman because He uses a Sword. Brook is not a Swordsman; He is a Musician that uses a sword.

**cross777** · 03-18-2011, 04:01 AM

yes because naruto is the only ninja in existence. LOL. and brook is kind of a swords men i mean its his main method of fighting. and i suspect that he learned to use his music? sound attacks through his sword.so..............

**Oni R.Li Roux** · 03-18-2011, 04:09 AM

The next member of the Strawhats should be a pirate that was a very powerful in the Navy before leaving and revolting against their corrupt ways by becoming a Pirate. I have a feeling that the next Strawhat will be a good friend of a fallen foe that was killed in the Marineford war, noticing Luffy's courageous efforts to save his brother and fighting against people like Sengoku,Moria,etc... The person will be very influence by Luffy's ways to save someone even when he is fighting foes that could kill him.

The next Strawhat will have a Bounty that is possibly 90,000,000 right of the back, however thats just speculation. I do think that they will be considered powerful or a coward, one of the other their lives will intertwine with the rest of the Strawhats and Luffy will want him to become his Nakama.

**FenixMarco** · 03-18-2011, 06:10 PM

Originally Posted by cross777

but if you think the swords men or woman idea is lame why are you still on the ninja idea? i mean its very likely if a ninja joins the crew he or she has a very good chance of using a sword.

I was actually seeing the Ninja as using a martial art form of fighting than anything. Since they don't have a martial art fighter (Aside from Chopper new form) She can easily show how her martial art belittles Choppers though, since she's trains all of her life for fighting unlike chopper who trains more to be a doctor than fighter and this is why Zoro > Sanji, Sanji just doesn't have the ambition for strength like Luffy and Zoro.But yes as a ninja she'll probably have weapon arsenal but unlikely a long sword like a swordsman like Zoro and Brooke. Half cut katana at most. Anyways it came from a long idea I had trying theorize about the Land of Wado that's been mentioned 3 times in One Piece already I had(Thriller Bark, Ace/Oars flash back and Green Book). But than I realize it was more of a fanfiction when I was trying put some pieces together.

Originally Posted by xioaxioa

A Swordsman is not a Swordsman because He uses a Sword. Brook is not a Swordsman; He is a Musician that uses a sword.

You bastard.

Originally Posted by Oni R.Li Roux

The next member of the Strawhats should be a pirate that was a very powerful in the Navy before leaving and revolting against their corrupt ways by becoming a Pirate. I have a feeling that the next Strawhat will be a good friend of a fallen foe that was killed in the Marineford war, noticing Luffy's courageous efforts to save his brother and fighting against people like Sengoku,Moria,etc... The person will be very influence by Luffy's ways to save someone even when he is fighting foes that could kill him.

The next Strawhat will have a Bounty that is possibly 90,000,000 right of the back, however thats just speculation. I do think that they will be considered powerful or a coward, one of the other their lives will intertwine with the rest of the Strawhats and Luffy will want him to become his Nakama.

This almost sounds like trying figure out what happen with Drake. Also think the idea of the next member joining because of being influence by Luffy that way is clearly already overused, reason why Oda didn't use it with Brooke. And pretty much made Franky the last one to join that way ending it with a bomb ass arc.

How I see the next member joining has to be largely connected with the World Government/revolutionary army's influence imo or it just won't be as interesting another point is something we have yet to know about in the New World although I doubt about this one, Oda has already added so much to this story.The Marines aren't portray as Villains by the way. It's going be something new that "hasn't" happen yet. And what we know exists but haven't gotten any circumstantial evidence about ? World Government, Revolutionary Army, Remaining Yonkou's, One Piece.

**dct21** · 03-18-2011, 06:52 PM

Originally Posted by xioaxioa

A Swordsman is not a Swordsman because He uses a Sword. Brook is not a Swordsman; He is a Musician that uses a sword.

Brook is a fencer

**cross777** · 03-18-2011, 07:50 PM

Originally Posted by FenixMarco

I was actually seeing the Ninja as using a martial art form of fighting than anything. Since they don't have a martial art fighter (Aside from Chopper new form) She can easily show how her martial art belittles Choppers though, since she's trains all of her life for fighting unlike chopper who trains more to be a doctor than fighter and this is why Zoro > Sanji, Sanji just doesn't have the ambition for strength like Luffy and Zoro.But yes as a ninja she'll probably have weapon arsenal but unlikely a long sword like a swordsman like Zoro and Brooke. Half cut katana at most. Anyways it came from a long idea I had trying theorize about the Land of Wado that's been mentioned 3 times in One Piece already I had(Thriller Bark, Ace/Oars flash back and Green Book). But than I realize it was more of a fanfiction when I was trying put some pieces together.

well i disagree about sanji but you have a point. but the thing is a swords a sword so..................... but i am actually starting to like your idea a bit. except the tom boy part. i mean i would like a ninja swords men i could deal with that.