^ Actiually all we did was sum up the facts why Caribou isn't strawhat-material.
Ofc we can't tell for certain why some one will or won't become a crewmember,
in the end it's Oda who decides it anyway.
But we can try to create some kind of profile of a possible next crew-member based on the situation at hand.
And the situation we got now certainly leans in a slightly good direction.
I don't see why u have a problem with that, this is what the thread is about anyway.
Btw, I don't think anyone has been using such simplistic reasons to begin with.