The Next Straw Hat Crew Member (During Punk Hazard Arc)

**cross777** · 12-04-2010, 01:35 AM

Originally Posted by xioaxioa

Wrong! Wrong! Wrong! The Kraken is not the new Vivi! Boa Hancock was the New Vivi and Luffy just departed from her. We won't have another Vivi character for awhile. A Vivi character is former enemy who turns out to be royalty who travels with Luffy to multiple destinations and then stays behind do to their own destiny that deals with the protection of their country. Currently the Kraken is in the same classification as Laboon, Mahmoo, and Luffy: All being pets to a pirate crew. You guys are just wrong when you say "This character is the new former character introduced some time ago." Like Caribou being the new Bellamy. Bellamy is the one who caused Merry to die, he is the one who created that impossible fix. Saying that Caribou is the new Bellamy is like saying the Thousand Sunny will be killed.

The Kraken is a Pet and, like the ship, will be a nakama but not count for the overall score of crew members.

you over analyzing a bit here X you should not count some one actions in to there character the part about bellamy does not make much sense becuase that is not what we mean when we say that. also by new viv every one mean some on that will join for a short run then leave boa was not like vivi because she never join the crew she just stalked luffy for a bit LOL.

and the krakken could go with them i just do not see it happening i mean it makes just as much sense to leave him on fish man island under lussy's control to help jimbi out and to bust him out when needed. point is i do not think the krakken will travel with them all the time. altoh X you have a great chance of being right with your idea to.

**Flare Blitz** · 12-04-2010, 11:35 AM

Yeah, it's 1 or the other.
I don't see it sacrefice itself right now @ the vulcano.

**daz bonez** · 12-04-2010, 05:52 PM

Originally Posted by cross777

you over analyzing a bit here X you should not count some one actions in to there character the part about bellamy does not make much sense becuase that is not what we mean when we say that. also by new viv every one mean some on that will join for a short run then leave boa was not like vivi because she never join the crew she just stalked luffy for a bit LOL.

and the krakken could go with them i just do not see it happening i mean it makes just as much sense to leave him on fish man island under lussy's control to help jimbi out and to bust him out when needed. point is i do not think the krakken will travel with them all the time. altoh X you have a great chance of being right with your idea to.

boa is the new vivi,she helped luffy infiltrate ID.helped her in war and his recovery.all the similarity with vivi including her backgroud and status is fit.i`ll first think that kraken is the same as laboon.but it`s different.laboon has a promise to keep.but not the kraken.and i don`t see aproblem with luffy being a davy jones.NW is full with nasty creatures, we don`t know when surume help will be needed.(like what he did with the umibouzu)
he even can take away some crew duties to collect food supllies.

**cross777** · 12-04-2010, 06:55 PM

yeah like you said its full of baddies probably some worse than him dont you think? and boa never joined the crew though thats the difference she was luffy's "friend" never a crew member. thats all i meant by that is that vivi was in the crew and boa was not. plus in the new world i would be worried about him being kind of like ours JR and just in the end being a big giant target.

**joshecalpoly** · 12-05-2010, 02:53 AM

Originally Posted by Flare Blitz

Yeah, it's 1 or the other.
I don't see it sacrefice itself right now @ the vulcano.

Eh it was more of a gut prediction and I think if he does it will seem as if he did but he will return later. The main reason I made that prediction is that I cant think of any ability that Nami Brooke or Ussop can do that would actually make sense not to mention they are out of fuel.

Pet or otherwise it is a nakama they can be nakama without joining. Chopper is considered a pet by the WG but also part of Luffys crew. I think he will be a pet or nakama that they will leave behind like Laboon was like Vivi was like Yokozuna was like many other friends that and animals that Luffy has left behind because they decided it was for the best not to have them continue on there journey

**cross777** · 12-05-2010, 04:22 AM

Originally Posted by joshecalpoly

Eh it was more of a gut prediction and I think if he does it will seem as if he did but he will return later. The main reason I made that prediction is that I cant think of any ability that Nami Brooke or Ussop can do that would actually make sense not to mention they are out of fuel.

Pet or otherwise it is a nakama they can be nakama without joining. Chopper is considered a pet by the WG but also part of Luffys crew. I think he will be a pet or nakama that they will leave behind like Laboon was like Vivi was like Yokozuna was like many other friends that and animals that Luffy has left behind because they decided it was for the best not to have them continue on there journey

well agree on most of this BUT vivi would be with them if she had made an effort to go you know. like if she said take me i am going with you they would have said lets go. and if she randomly showed up and said i want in she would be in (B4 any one starts i know this is 100% unlikely i am just making a point.)