The Next Straw Hat Crew Member (During Punk Hazard Arc)

[cross777]

no its not out of 16 deviation commanders about 5-6 out of the 16 of them are swords men thats about on swords man commander for every 2 none swords men commanders. so it would be perfectly fine if they got another one

[Flare Blitz]

Nah, we allready have Zoro and in a way Brook as swordsmen,
and zoros goal pretty much is every swordsmans dream.
It just wouldn't fit anywhere into the (rather unusual) crew in my opinion,
and no matter where he/she would be ranked Among the SHs crew i won't be too happy.

[cross777]

brooks dream is not to be the worlds greatest swords men and a new swords men could have another dream and having more than 2 swords men in a crew is nothing rare

[Flare Blitz]

That's the problem, it's nothing rare :p
and that doesn't fit in the SH-crew lol

[cross777]

That's the problem, it's nothing rare :p
and that doesn't fit in the SH-crew lol

there are thousands of swords and thousands of styles that oda cna mix and match to make it cool now i agree oda should not spam swords in the straw hats BUT one more would be really cool

[Sir Chaos]

It is good that boa hancock because she is the queen...

Best post in this thread.

[Roshi]

Brook really isn't a swordsman. Just a musician that happens to use a sword. That's why for the past 2 years he has been powering up his music rather than practicing with a blade.

I think that any additional crew members will either have a DF or will use their job in to fight in some way... So any sword use will either be like Trafalgar (which aids his DF ability) or like Brook where he uses the sword to augment his job-type fighting (music).

[FenixMarco]

ahhhhhhhh...no more swordsman two is more than enough....

if a female..i like her to be a some kind of spy/stealth type...to counter lafitte..maybe wearing a cloak to make her more mysterious ...that would be cool...

Like Roshi said we don't really need a spy role even though was picturing a ninja before but think the Tomboy to be some type of martial artist.

Swordsman would be wack yeah, he's not going to be better at it than Zoro and can't suck more than brooke's or it be pointless.

[cross777]

Brook really isn't a swordsman. Just a musician that happens to use a sword. That's why for the past 2 years he has been powering up his music rather than practicing with a blade.

I think that any additional crew members will either have a DF or will use their job in to fight in some way... So any sword use will either be like Trafalgar (which aids his DF ability) or like Brook where he uses the sword to augment his job-type fighting (music).

true good point and that would not be that bad either or zoro could get an apprentice LOL but a DF user swords man would be cool and unique. PLUS we dont really know if brook improved his swords man ship with music so he could be much better.

[Maximo]

Do the Straw Hats need any new crewmate ? My only argument would be that they lack the female power in theyre ranks. Boa ? I think it should be a powerful women. Robin and Nami are not fighters. Luffies crew needs a female warrior !! On a level of Sanji unleast !! That should be enough.