
Originally Posted by
artifice
Its an interesting situation because assuming Tobi was created by Madara transfering his own memories into a new body it makes me wonder just how much they are the same. Based on what we have seen of both of them they really don't seem to have the same personality. Madara himself seems to crave battle and enjoy conflict, Tobi on the other hand seems to prefer staying in the shadows and pulling strings. Tobi seems to have more of an attitude of only doing what is necessary to win where as Madara seems to enjoy the challenge of the fight, commonly baiting and belittling his opponents. Tobi does enjoy messing with his enemies but not really in the same way, when it comes to business he really just seems to call it straight, he doesn't have the same level of bravado. Madara knows he is powerful and likes to rub it in everyone's face, he likes to show off and put his power on display. It is actually hard to think of Madara as the one who came up with the moon's eye plan, based on his attitude I don't really see why he would want everyone to become docile slaves of the Eternal Tsukuyomi.
So the question is, what accounts for this difference? Perhaps Tobi's personality differs somewhat from Madara's because his relative lack of power forced him to live in the shadows for so many years and he could no longer afford to be as openly aggressive as Madara is/was. The interesting thing is though, Madara does seem to be the one who came up with the Moon's Eye plan since he mentions it during his battle with the Kage's. So it doesn't seem to be a case of diverging intentions, both Tobi and Madara do seem to have the same objective despite their apparent differences in personality.
I agree with you though that Tobi does seem like the more interesting villain. Madara seems almost childishly arrogant, his boasting and insulting attitude makes him seem like a kid who never got over his inferiority complex. The way he constantly compares everyone to Hashirama makes it seem like he still hasn't gotten over the fact that he lost many decades ago and he is just lashing out at everyone because he wants to be seen as the strongest. Tobi on the other hand seems more complex, he doesn't really seem to be as interested in petty recognition or simply surpassing Hashirama. Tobi seems like someone who has bigger ideas and isn't petty enough to get hung up on the results of a mere fight. Although I do think that the Moon's Eye plan is kind of lame. Personally, I thought Orochimaru's ambition of learning the truth behind everything, mastering the secrets of the world and creating new ones was far more interesting. Tobi's plan is a very big and threatening idea though, and Tobi at least conducts himself like someone with big ideas and complex motives. Madara so far just doesn't hold up, perhaps the difference is just a result of Tobi's ambiguity but we will have to wait and see.
Bookmarks