How would you guys react if..........

**z3n0cid3** · 12-06-2007, 06:18 PM

for those of you who dono the theory, here's the link
The Dark History of Uchiha: The Bloodline of Tengu <SPOILERS WILL GET YOU BANNED> - Naruto Forums

I'd like y'all to stop calling it a theory, since it is based on very limited evidence and has not been proven, so it's a hypothesis and at best hypothetical theory (yikes). It's safe to say this is put together the few tengus drawn in the manga to back it up, an active imagination and some quick reading.

then what would you call it? if there WAS evidence then that doesnt make it a theory -_-... of course it hasnt been proven, thats why its just a theory, a speculation.

**Arhazivory** · 12-07-2007, 03:18 AM

I just read the theory and it's very well put together. But, that's all it is really...a very well put together theory. It really is rather like fanfiction (many theories available) AND therefore is NOT LIKELY to occur.

It was very interesting though, especially how different scenes of the manga were put together in support of the theory.

**tatsukai1990** · 12-08-2007, 04:56 AM

well i normally stay out of this dark closet of mangashare, but i wanna know who else besides myself and some others, hate the tengu theory. destroy the theory here.

**Dabarnes** · 12-08-2007, 10:14 AM

It's not a theory, it's just fan fiction with a bunch of pictures.

**damnz** · 12-08-2007, 10:18 AM

It's not about hating or destroying that, it's just a fanfiction, you can believe it will happen or not, but nothing more, I think...

PS: Merging this with the Tengu theory thread.

**Kendoki** · 12-08-2007, 04:10 PM

How is discussing an obviously flawed theory, a theory?

Learn where to post your threads.

**gradoman** · 12-08-2007, 04:28 PM

then what would you call it? if there WAS evidence then that doesnt make it a theory -_-... of course it hasnt been proven, thats why its just a theory, a speculation.

You'd call it a hypothesis, not a theory. And that's what I said, it's a hypothesis; at best hypothetical theory since the originator of this hypothesis is building on suppositions, not fact or canon and without any facts or evidence to support his hypothesis it doesn't make logical sense.

In other words, he's trying to go from 1+X = ? to 1+X=10. Can't do that missing the answer, now, can you?

**Arhazivory** · 12-08-2007, 09:03 PM

LOL...the theory doesn't warrant this much discussion. It should stay where it is...in the backroom....a well-put together theory in the backroom.

**Rainierman** · 12-08-2007, 11:37 PM

oh, So it originated from Narutofan forums. The many places I've seen them, they didn't have author or anything of that sort, and I looked for it. Which contributed for me to think it was leaked.

Now I see it as a very well put theory, niice.

**draciel** · 12-09-2007, 03:17 PM

I would hope Kishimoto(I think)(?)(can't seem to remember... you know, that guy who does the drawings and wrights the history) to improvise is way out of there.

The tengu theory is just like me suddenly saying that Naruto will disappear for a wHile, find his mother, learn the FTGT and return to save evryone, presenting as proofs that Naruto has to learn it, since it's such a MF(stands for moth... f.....) technique, and show some img of Minato owning someone with it as a proof that it's the only way to defeat Pain - it's more a fanfic than a theory on itself. It's just a well put story (though as my sign say we will be seeing a lot more of it now....I was antecipating this ever since the other chapter...).