Rate that (sig) Banner

Srry 'bout that Roku, I can see it now (guess it was my com)

Sig:8/10

Looks good just that light by Nagato is a little strong, other than that it's great

8/10

8/10 - some more effects and textures would have been a little better ^^

6/10

Since I dont use a classic sig, rate this one I made recently instead
http://i728.photobucket.com/albums/w...MugetsuSig.png

10/10

Rate Mine Please^

^okay^

its 5/10 I guess :S I dont like the gif and Aizens parody wasnt that funny..

Additional ratings :

@Kyosuke - 6.8/10 I like the composition and renders but your sig is still just half-way to perfection. Theres so much potential for lightning effects that I almost made a tear :D Really, do something with lightning ! The same for shading. Colours are too monoton, which makes it less eye-catching. Last thing, be carefull with smudging and blurring :S

@Jaiden - 7.1/10 Basically the same thing as Kyosuke minus the colours, although Captian Amercia is cooler so props for that :3

@ maxi 7-10 thw white area is killing me

O-E-M, not sure if the spoiler tag is ur sig, but I won't give a grade on this.

@Max: 7/10 I gotta agree with OEM on this one the white space on the right is a dead-zone, the effects are straight. Also, the colors are a bit monotone. and the text kinda ruins it, well, the Mugetsu part anyway. Other than that, it's solid.

7/10 Add a border and change the place where the spotlight or lighting is...doesn't do much where it is, besides that, high quality stuff

4/10

Okay, the biggest problem with this for me is there's no flow. Everything seems spread out, and just randomly placed. Text is TOO unreadable, sure, text isn't supposed to stand out, but this blends in too much. Also, whatever that is on the far right ( I think that's a C4D, I dunno) it's a bit distracting from the focal. Your colors a too bland and don't really "pop out" your render looks dull, and this sig lacks depth. Not trying to sound rude or anything, just trying to help. Also, a border isn't really needed. To me, and a lot of others, there's no point to one. Anyway, just look at some tuts, and build on that for the future. Hope this helps.