Lol.. tons of ugly character in One Piece, and that's make this anime cool. hahahaha
Ooh~ what an ouch-ful poll. lol. My vote goes to Alvida pre-make over. She embodies the "anti-hot" concept.
this would answer your question =3 (scroll down a bit to "page 66")
Lola. even ugly than Kokoro imo
Oda did an SBS later about this. A reader asked "Why was Jyabura dumped?" Oda answered "Gatherine fell in love with Rob Lucci. Thus it explains the rivalry between Lucci and Jyabura." ....or something like that.
Gatherine has to be insane to fall in love with Lucci.
Maybe she likes guys that could tear her into pieces. :s
Bon clay, no contest. That guy just scared me.
And thinking of Alvida makes me go back to when One piece was in it's first chapters; the art's come on a long way since then. Huh, as for Naruto, Kishi's no better at creating characters with distinct genders now than he was in the Zabuza arc.
The weird part is that the above applies to the anime as well. The start of One Piece anime, even the original, wasn't all that charming. But as Toei throw more money into it, the anime gets better and better, especially visually.