Your assessment was correct.
http://img514.imageshack.us/img514/7710/hohozq6.gif
Club Member Insanity Ranking
http://img161.imageshack.us/img161/879/edufr5.gif
In the order starting from the disillusioned time travelers, to the insane espers, to the barmy aliens, and then ends with regular humans:
1. draciel <----Congratulations, draciel! You are #1 ! If you are wondering why you are #1, just go ahead and read one of your own posts and you will understand. ^^
2. Redsquirrel <---the guy who preferred the dub version
3. Asce <----Nobody likes to be dissected, Mr. sadist!
http://img161.imageshack.us/img161/7716/pekxd2.png
4. Minidevi <-----This person is way up there in the Haruhi fanatic level. The vast majority of his post counts are solely devoted to the glory of the Brigade. While loyalty is a good thing, obsession is yet another. This kid's obsession with Haruhi-sama is so great, that so much so even the Brigade Chief himself was no exception to his death threats for offending Haruhi-sama's name in the slightest of fashion. Tsk, it's not as if Haruhi would ever reward your loyalty by sleeping with you in bed.
http://img341.imageshack.us/img341/3165/hmlolkz3ry2.png
5. Binky <---- Cat God worshiper. Just let you know, I do respect cats. ^^
6. DukeTheGold <----You know that the world is going to be turned into a giant Disney Land when this guy conquers the world. First decree in his new world order: replace all Mickey Mouses with bunny girls.
http://img341.imageshack.us/img341/3165/hmlolkz3ry2.png
7. Arhazivory <----The queen of the Boredom Zone, where death roll prisoners, school shooters in training, mafia bosses, professional rapists, underground drug traffickers, child predators, evil bunny girls and death eaters from Harry Potter gathers. Now that's gotta speak for something! To be the master of evils(or for merely wanting to be one), the queen majesty herself must be pretty screwed up in the head as well, not to mention that she adopted Fuzzy and Kikiz as her children, which is weird.
http://img262.imageshack.us/img262/5761/zarund5.gif
8. Sangaz <----From what I know, this guy is pretty insane as well. He devotes the majority of his time worshiping naked anime girls who were drawn by 30+ year old men.
9. ReshenKusaga <---- A bit off in the nuts and bolts area. But he's perfectly fine when compared to the rest of us. ^^
10. Archiel <----Perfectly normal at first glance. But it's a proven fact that your screws must be loose somewhere in the head when you join the ranks of Moderators and Administrators. It's one of Blud's unofficial requirements. ^^
11. jja <----bottom last. A perfectly average specimen of the Homo sapiens bipedal primate race. No comments. ^^
Inactive members and new members are not included in the list. So Pakkun and gin0va, you guys better get your asses back in here if you want your sanity rated.
http://img161.imageshack.us/img161/7716/pekxd2.png